Should You Retain or Trade Semenyo? Insights for Fantasy Premier League Managers

Antoine Semenyo has made an impressive entrance into his tenure with Manchester City, netting two goals in his initial cup appearances. This performance has sparked a debate among Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers: do you hold onto him or consider parting ways now that he’s competing for a starting spot?

The Semenyo Situation

As the focal point during his time at Bournemouth, Semenyo proved crucial for many FPL players. However, his transition to Manchester City raises questions about his future role.

In an upcoming match against Manchester United, he has earned a spot in the team of the week, reigniting discussions on his value in FPL.

Expert opinions from FPL analyst Prasun Singhal and others offer insights on the pros and cons of keeping Semenyo in your lineup.

The Dilemma: Keep or Trade?

Reasons to Keep Semenyo

Prasun Singhal: “With 10 goals this season, Semenyo ranks as one of the top point scorers in FPL. His performance could see a boost given Manchester City’s attack.”

Furthermore, as City strives to catch up with Arsenal after a series of draws, there is a need for impactful players like Semenyo right now.

Statman Dave adds: “I would recommend retaining him. If you don’t yet have him, wait to see if he features consistently. He fits smoothly into City’s system and might even surpass Phil Foden as a valuable asset by season’s end.”

Reasons to Sell Semenyo

Prasun Singhal: “Joining a more extensive squad implies Semenyo won’t have a guaranteed 90 minutes, reducing his opportunities for set-pieces and penalties.”

Given that City is engaged in multiple competitions as the season progresses, I would lean towards selling him now. However, if you already have him, keeping him for the Week 23 match against Wolves may be worthwhile.

Chris Sutton notes rumors suggesting Semenyo might not start against Manchester United, adding uncertainty regarding his immediate value.

Managing Multiple Manchester City Players

Prasun Singhal: “FPL regulations cap teams at three players from any single club. Thus, if acquiring Semenyo brings your City roster to four, you’ll need to offload one player in your next transfer. However, you can keep all four active until you’re ready to make a move.”

This cap means careful management is essential when considering roster depth with high-performing teams like Manchester City.

Overall, the decision to keep or trade Semenyo hinges on your unique FPL strategy and how his role evolves within a competitive squad.