Five Promising Clubs for Manchester Citys Disgruntled Goalkeeper James Trafford
James Trafford’s Future: Five Potential Clubs for the Young Goalkeeper
With James Trafford sidelined at Manchester City, let’s explore five teams he might consider joining.
It’s difficult not to sympathize with Trafford. The 23-year-old had an exceptional 2024-25 season with Burnley, which earned him a chance to return to his childhood club. However, his timing coincided with Manchester City acquiring arguably the best goalkeeper globally.
Joining Manchester City, a team striving for success on multiple fronts, meant facing stiff competition. Unfortunately, since Gianluigi Donnarumma’s arrival, Trafford has yet to see any action in the Premier League.
Given this situation, it appears Trafford may seek a departure from Man City soon to secure more consistent playing time. Here are five clubs we believe might suit him.
1. Chelsea
This could represent an ideal opportunity for Trafford. Since Thibaut Courtois’s exit in 2018, Chelsea has struggled with their goalkeeper situation, though Robert Sanchez has shown some promise this season.
While Trafford may not instantly become the first-choice keeper, there could be openings for him to establish himself as Chelsea’s number one, especially considering Filip Jorgensen’s struggles with the role.
Chelsea’s history of signing former Man City academy players, including Cole Palmer, Liam Delap, and Romeo Lavia, could ease his transition. Ultimately, the move would rely on the club’s interest rather than Trafford’s willingness.
2. Tottenham
While securing a new goalkeeper may not be high on Tottenham’s agenda, there have been questions regarding Vicario’s performances this season, particularly in matches against Aston Villa and Manchester United.
Though Trafford may not secure the starting position immediately, he possesses a superior long-ball success rate, compensating for a lower save percentage than Vicario.
Bringing in Trafford could also fulfill Spurs’ home-grown player quota, where they currently lack one player to meet the Premier League minimum of eight. This limits their ability to register a full squad.
3. Newcastle
Newcastle appeared poised to sign Trafford before Manchester City intervened, snatching him from under their noses. After a shaky transfer window, they managed to stabilize their squad.
Nick Pope has been solid, boasting five clean sheets and conceding only 12 goals across 11 games. However, Newcastle’s decision to not pursue a goalkeeper following the Trafford window indicates ongoing interest in him.
That said, Newcastle’s primary focus seems to be on addressing their difficulties in attack, as they’ve only netted 11 goals this season, thus prioritizing a creative midfielder instead.
4. Burnley
While returning to Burnley might be seen as a backward step for Trafford, it could provide a familiar environment that may restore his confidence. A loan deal would be the most logical option, considering Burnley’s current battle against relegation.
Trafford’s previous performance with Burnley—only conceding 16 goals in 45 league matches—outshines their current keeper, Martin Dubravka, making him a valuable addition.
5. Aston Villa
There are whispers that Emi Martinez’s commitment to Aston Villa is wavering. The Argentine had sought a transfer earlier in the summer, with Manchester United reportedly expressing interest, yet no move materialized.
His recent game against Liverpool showcased some troubling moments, contributing to the team’s defeat. Despite a bounce-back in subsequent matches, Villa’s financial issues—stemming from excessive wage expenditures—present challenges. However, securing Trafford could offer a solid long-term solution in goal.